Context: We recently described a patient with chronic lymphocytic leukemia who presented with a breast carcinoma that stained positive for CD5 using a commercially available antibody (CD5-4C7, Novocastra, Newcastle upon Tyne, UK).
Objectives: To study the distribution of CD5 immunoreactivity in tissue sections of a variety of benign and malignant breast lesions using the antibody CD5-4C7 and to compare the results with those obtained with 2 other commercially available CD5 antibodies (CD5/54/F6, Dako, Ely, Cambridgeshire, UK, and CD5/54/B4, Novocastra).
Design: Paraffin sections of 102 breast biopsy specimens with various diagnoses were examined using the avidin-biotin immunoperoxidase complex technique.
Setting: The histopathology department of a tertiary referral teaching hospital.
Results: The staining results obtained with CD5-4C7 were different from those obtained with the other 2 antibodies. With 4C7, the normal and benign biopsy specimens showed varying numbers of positive epithelial cells and lymphocytes. Heterogeneous positive staining was also present in 47 (78%) of 60 invasive female breast carcinomas and in all 3 male breast carcinomas examined. A statistically significant correlation was found between CD5 positivity and tumor grade, with grade 3 tumors being less likely to be CD5 positive than grades 1 and 2 (P =.0035). No correlation was found between CD5 positivity and patient's age, tumor histologic type, axillary lymph node status, or progesterone receptors. On the other hand, the CD5/54/F6 and CD5/54/B4 antibodies only stained lymphocytes and occasional normal breast ducts, mostly those showing apocrine metaplasia. All other normal benign and malignant epithelial cells were negative.
Conclusions: Positive staining for CD5 using the antibody 4C7 is seen in normal and benign breast tissue and 78% of invasive breast carcinomas. The positivity is more common in low-grade tumors. No significant staining was seen with the 2 other CD5 clones used in this study. The significance of the positive staining obtained with CD5-4C7 is not obvious, but this clone may be more sensitive than the others, or it may be recognizing an epitope shared by another antigen.