A randomised trial of mastectomy only versus tamoxifen for treating elderly patients with operable primary breast cancer-final results at 20-year follow-up

Abstract

A recent Cochrane review of trials involving elderly women with operable primary breast cancer showed no significant difference in overall survival between surgery (±adjuvant tamoxifen) and primary endocrine therapy using tamoxifen. We report the final results of a randomised pilot trial comparing primary tamoxifen and wedge mastectomy as initial treatment in this population. One hundred and thirty-one women >70 years with early operable primary breast cancer (<5 cm), unselected for oestrogen receptor (ER), entered the trial in 1982-1987. Sixty-eight patients were allocated to tamoxifen only and 67 to wedge mastectomy only, as primary treatment. At 20 years of follow-up, the median time to local failure was significantly shorter in the tamoxifen arm though approximately one-fifth of patients in this group did not develop local failure requiring mastectomy. There was no difference in regional recurrence, distant metastases or overall survival between the mastectomy and tamoxifen arms. In this small study, primary endocrine therapy achieved local control in 30% of those surviving at 5 years and 20% at 10 years, unselected for ER. The primary therapy used did not significantly affect regional recurrence, incidence of distant metastases or overall survival. Primary endocrine therapy should certainly be considered in those patients with ER positive tumours and who are unfit (based on life expectancy) for or refuse surgery.