Gynaecological laparoscopic surgery for benign conditions: do women care about incisions?

Abstract

Objective: To determine the relevance of the number and location of incisions in women undergoing gynaecologic laparoscopy due to benign conditions.

Study design: This study included 141 women, who underwent gynaecologic laparoscopic surgery with 4 incisions due to benign conditions between November 2010 and November 2011 at the University Medical Centre Mannheim, Germany. Women with malign histology were excluded. Demographic parameters, type and duration of surgery, perioperative complications and duration of hospital stay were analysed. Women were contacted using a standardized telephone survey with an interval of at least 22 weeks after surgery. Patients were interviewed regarding the number, postoperative pain and their preferences for omission of incisions.

Results: Eighty-seven women (61.7%) responded to the standardized questionnaire. 38 (43.7%) remembered the number of incisions correctly. 45 of the women (51.7%) thought they had less, 4 (4.6%) thought, they had more incisions as they actually did have. If one of the incisions had to be discarded 28 (32.2%) patients did not have any preferences with regard to the localisation. Of the other 59 patients, 44 (74.6%) would prefer to eliminate the umbilical one.

Conclusion: The majority of the women remembered fewer incisions than actually used. Most of the patients interviewed would, if possible, eliminate the umbilical incision. Therefore from the patient's perspective the skin scars after conventional laparoscopic surgery seem to be of limited importance and the alleged advantage of omission of additional incision using single site surgery remains debatable.