Liver resection is recognized as the preferred treatment for patients with colorectal liver metastases (CLM) because it offers long-term survival; it is the only hope for a cure. However, in the majority of cases, liver surgery is contraindicated due to the small volume of the future remnant liver. To extend the surgical indications for CLM, a planned two-stage hepatectomy procedure with portal vein embolization (PVE) was developed specifically for patients with multiple and bilobar CLM. The rationale for performing the procedure was a concern about the possible overgrowth of intrafuture remnant liver lesions following PVE, and it was therefore recommended for all multiple bilobar CLM cases, even when one-stage hepatectomy was technically feasible. We recently performed Hobson's choice two-stage hepatectomy in two cases for reasons different from those of the original planned two-stage hepatectomy. In the present report, we describe our Hobson's choice two-stage hepatectomy strategy, which provided favorable short-term outcomes.