Numerical simulation of the effect of inhalation parameters, gender, age and disease severity on the lung deposition of dry powder aerosol drugs emitted by Turbuhaler®, Breezhaler® and Genuair® in COPD patients

Abstract

The effect of breathing parameters on the airway deposition of the inhaled aerosols with known size was intensively studied in the literature. However, in the case of dry powder aerosol drugs both the quantity and quality of the particles emitted by the inhaler and inhaled by the patients is a complex function of the patient's breathing parameters, which in turn depend also on the disease severity and current status of the patient. The aim of this study was to evaluate the impact of breathing parameters, gender, age, symptoms and exacerbation history related disease severity (GOLD groups) of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) patients on the lung dose of four different drugs emitted by three DPIs (dry powder inhalers). Breathing profiles of 47 COPD patients were recorded while they inhaled through Turbuhaler®, Breezhaler® and Genuair® inhalers. Patient specific emitted doses and particle size distributions were determined for Symbicort® Turbuhaler®, Onbrez® Breezhaler®, Seebri® Breezhaler® and Bretaris® Genuair® aerosol drugs. Airway deposition was quantified by a validated whole respiratory tract particle deposition model. Correlation analysis of the lung doses with breathing parameters through the devices and with standard spirometric parameters was performed. The effects of gender, age and degree of disease severity (GOLD groups) on the lung doses were also studied by statistical analysis. Mean values and distributions of the deposited lung doses proved to be both drug and device specific, yielding 24.2 (±7.8), 22.6 (±3.6), 34.2 (±4.8) and 23.9 (±5.4) % values for Symbicort®, Onbrez®, Seebri® and Bretaris®, respectively. Drugs with flow rate sensitive emitted dose and emitted particle size distribution exhibited higher intersubject variability of the lung doses. The degree of correlation of lung doses with breathing parameters through the devices was also drug specific. Correlation with flow rate was the strongest for Symbicort® Turbuhaler®. Longer breath-hold increased the lung dose of all the studied drugs. Correlations of lung dose with standard spirometric parameters was generally weaker than its correlation with the parameters measured when inhaling through the devices. Men had higher lung deposition than women, younger patients had higher deposition than older ones and patients with less severe disease higher doses than those with more severe COPD, but the differences were statistically significant only upon gender and only in case of Symbicort® and Seebri®. Patients with better inhalation parameters are likely to have higher lung deposition when inhaling a drug with emitted dose and particle size distribution sensitive to the inhalation flow rate. At the same time, patients with lower lung capacity show better deposition results when inhaling from inhalers emitting a more constant amount of drug and particles with more stable aerodynamic characteristics. A more powerful inhalation significantly increases the lung dose for the drug emitted by Turbuhaler®, while long breath-hold is likely to yield significantly higher deposition for drugs emitted by Breezhaler® and Genuair®. Lung doses of two different drugs dispensed in the same inhaler can be significantly different.

Keywords: Breath-hold; Breezhaler®; Drug deposition; Flow rate; Genuair®; Turbuhaler®.