The Efficacy of Clinical Breast Exams and Breast Self-Exams in Detecting Malignancy or Positive Ultrasound Findings

Nicole Huang; Lu Chen; Jing He; Quan D Nguyen

doi:10.7759/cureus.22464

The Efficacy of Clinical Breast Exams and Breast Self-Exams in Detecting Malignancy or Positive Ultrasound Findings

Cureus. 2022 Feb 21;14(2):e22464. doi: 10.7759/cureus.22464. eCollection 2022 Feb.

Authors

Nicole Huang¹, Lu Chen², Jing He³, Quan D Nguyen⁴

Affiliations

¹ Internal Medicine, University of Texas (UT) Dell Medical School, Austin, USA.
² Biostatistics and Epidemiology, University of Texas Medical Branch (UTMB), Galveston, USA.
³ Pathology, University of Texas Medical Branch (UTMB), Galveston, USA.
⁴ Radiology, Baylor College of Medicine, Houston, USA.

Abstract

Objective A breast exam is a low-risk, low-cost method for early detection, which is crucial for improved mortality. However, clinical breast exams (CBE) and breast self-exams (BSEs) remain controversial with unclear guidelines. This study analyzes the efficacy of these two exam types in evaluating palpable breast masses. Methods This retrospective cross-sectional study included 2019 medical records from Epic of women with breast lumps. Patient demographics, provider types, and breast exam types were recorded. Primary outcomes were detection of cancer and positive ultrasound finding. Fisher's exact tests and two-sample t-tests determined the statistical significance of the association between the outcomes and categorical and continuous variables. Results Of 462 breast masses, 69 demonstrated positive ultrasound findings, with 26 of those yielding cancer; 96% of cancers and 81% of ultrasound findings resulted from patient-identified lumps. Of provider-identified lumps, 100% of cancers and 92.3% of positive ultrasound findings were diagnosed by MDs (doctors of medicine) rather than midlevel providers. There was no statistically significant difference in identifying cancer or positive ultrasound finding between CBEs and BSEs (p = 0.3709 and p = 0.1556). Conclusion Despite no difference between CBEs and BSEs in identifying cancer or positive ultrasound finding, 25 of the 26 breast cancers were initially detected by patients, while only one of 26 was detected by CBE. BSEs detect breast cancers. Although some guidelines encourage CBEs over self-exams, not all CBEs are equal. Key message There is no significant difference between CBEs and BSEs in identifying cancer or positive ultrasound finding. The majority of cancers were initially identified by patients. BSEs detect breast cancers and women should continue performing them. Not all CBEs are equal. CBEs by MDs, especially women health specialists, are generally more effective than those by midlevel providers.

Keywords: breast cancer; breast lumps; breast self-exams; breast-radiology-mammography-ultrasound-mri-biopsyelastography; clinical breast exams.