Normics: Proteomic Normalization by Variance and Data-Inherent Correlation Structure

Abstract

Several algorithms for the normalization of proteomic data are currently available, each based on a priori assumptions. Among these is the extent to which differential expression (DE) can be present in the dataset. This factor is usually unknown in explorative biomarker screens. Simultaneously, the increasing depth of proteomic analyses often requires the selection of subsets with a high probability of being DE to obtain meaningful results in downstream bioinformatical analyses. Based on the relationship of technical variation and (true) biological DE of an unknown share of proteins, we propose the "Normics" algorithm: Proteins are ranked based on their expression level-corrected variance and the mean correlation with all other proteins. The latter serves as a novel indicator of the non-DE likelihood of a protein in a given dataset. Subsequent normalization is based on a subset of non-DE proteins only. No a priori information such as batch, clinical, or replicate group is necessary. Simulation data demonstrated robust and superior performance across a wide range of stochastically chosen parameters. Five publicly available spike-in and biologically variant datasets were reliably and quantitively accurately normalized by Normics with improved performance compared to standard variance stabilization as well as median, quantile, and LOESS normalizations. In complex biological datasets Normics correctly determined proteins as being DE that had been cross-validated by an independent transcriptome analysis of the same samples. In both complex datasets Normics identified the most DE proteins. We demonstrate that combining variance analysis and data-inherent correlation structure to identify non-DE proteins improves data normalization. Standard normalization algorithms can be consolidated against high shares of (one-sided) biological regulation. The statistical power of downstream analyses can be increased by focusing on Normics-selected subsets of high DE likelihood.

Keywords: Data normalization; Differential expression analysis; Omics data; Protein quantitation; Proteomics.