Orphan cytotoxins are small molecules for which the mechanism of action (MoA) is either unknown or ambiguous. Unveiling the mechanism of these compounds may lead to useful tools for biological investigation and in some cases, new therapeutic leads. In select cases, the DNA mismatch repair-deficient colorectal cancer cell line, HCT116, has been used as a tool in forward genetic screens to identify compound-resistant mutations, which have ultimately led to target identification. To expand the utility of this approach, we engineered cancer cell lines with inducible mismatch repair deficits, thus providing temporal control over mutagenesis. By screening for compound resistance phenotypes in cells with low or high rates of mutagenesis, we increased both the specificity and sensitivity of identifying resistance mutations. Using this inducible mutagenesis system, we implicate targets for multiple orphan cytotoxins, including a natural product and compounds emerging from a high-throughput screen, thus providing a robust tool for future MoA studies.