Does use of ankle foot orthoses affect the dynamic motor control index during walking in cerebral palsy and idiopathic toe walking populations?

Abstract

Background: The dynamic motor control (walk-DMC) index during walking is a measure of the complexity of muscle activation pattern. Ankle Foot Orthoses (AFO) are frequently used to improve the gait of children with Cerebral Palsy (CP) and Idiopathic Toe Walking (ITW). The purpose of this study was to assess the change in walk-DMC index secondary to AFO use.

Research question: Does the change in walk-DMC reflect the change in walking kinematics with the use of AFO.

Methods: Individuals with diagnosis of CP or ITW with gait analysis data available for barefoot and AFO condition were retrospectively identified. For each individual, the walk-DMC index, Gait Deviation Index (GDI) and Gait Variable Scores (GVS) of knee and ankle kinematics were computed for BF and AFO conditions. Paired t-tests were used to compare key variables between BF and AFO conditions. Multi-variate stepwise regression analysis was performed to identify variables that may predict the increase in walk-DMC between BF and AFO condition.

Results: 253 individuals were included in the study. For CP individuals (n = 208), statistically significant but quantitatively minimal improvement was observed in walk-DMC (1 ± 9), GDI (2 ± 9) and ankle GVS (2 ± 7). For ITW individuals (n = 45), larger improvements were observed in walk-DMC (11 ± 13), GDI (9 ± 11) and ankle GVS (6 ± 7). Diagnosis of ITW, use of Solid-AFO and Posterior Leaf Spring-AFO were the significant predictor of increase in walk-DMC with AFO. Higher ankle GVS at BF condition (larger deviation from TD) led to larger increase in walk-DMC. Higher knee GVS (larger deviation from TD) led to smaller increase in walk-DMC.

Significance: Use of AFO can lead to improvement in walking kinematics that is reflected in increase in walk-DMC with AFO compared to BF for ITW individuals. The change in kinematics and walk-DMC with use of AFO was minimal for CP individuals.

Keywords: AFO; Ankle Foot Orthosis; Cerebral palsy; Dynamic Motor Control; Idiopathic toe walking; Walk-DMC.