Biomechanical Forces of the Lateral Knee Joint Following Meniscectomy and Meniscus Transplantation in Pediatric Cadavers

Abstract

Introduction: Lateral meniscus transplantation successfully treats symptomatic meniscus deficiency in children. Although clinical outcomes are well-characterized, joint forces in meniscus-deficient and transplant states are unknown. The purpose of this study was to characterize contact area (CA) and contact pressures (CP) of transplanted lateral meniscus in pediatric cadavers. We hypothesize that (1) compared with the intact state, meniscectomy will decrease femorotibial CA and increase CP, and increase contact pressure (CP) and (2) compared with the meniscectomy state, meniscus transplantation will improve contact biomechanics toward the intact meniscus state.

Methods: Pressure-mapping sensors were inserted underneath the lateral meniscus of eight cadaver knees aged 8 to 12 years. CA and CP on the lateral tibial plateau were measured in the intact, meniscectomy, and transplant states each at 0°, 30°, and 60° of knee flexion. Meniscus transplant was anchored with transosseous pull-out sutures and sutured to the joint capsule with vertical mattresses. The effects of meniscus states and flexion angle on CA and CP were measured by a two-way analysis of variance repeated measures model. One-way analysis of variance measured pairwise comparisons between meniscus states.

Results: Regarding CA, at 0°, no differences between the groups reached significance. Meniscectomy reduced CA at 30° ( P = 0.043) and 60° ( P = 0.001). Transplant and intact states were comparable at 30°. At 60°, transplant significantly increased CA ( P = 0.04). Regarding contact pressure, the average pressure increased with meniscectomy at all angles of flexion (0° P = 0.025; 30° P = 0.021; 60° P = 0.016) and decreased with transplant relative to respective intact values. Peak pressure increased with meniscectomy at 30° ( P = 0.009) and 60° ( P = 0.041), but only reached intact comparable values at 60°. Pairwise comparisons support restoration of average CP with transplant, but not peak CP.

Discussion: Pediatric meniscus transplantation improves average CP and CA more than peak CP, but does not completely restore baseline biomechanics. Net improvements in contact biomechanics after transplant, relative to the meniscectomy state, support meniscus transplant.

Study design: Descriptive laboratory study, Level III.