Is peak hamstrings muscle-tendon length criterion a sufficient indicator to recommend against surgical lengthening of hamstrings?

Abstract

Background: Excessive knee flexion during stance in children with cerebral palsy is often treated by surgical hamstrings lengthening. Pre-operative hamstrings muscle-tendon length can be estimated from kinematics and often used for decision making to rule out surgical lengthening if peak hamstrings muscle-tendon length is 'Not Short'.

Research question: If peak hamstrings muscle-tendon length is within two standard deviations of typical, is that a sufficient indicator to rule out surgical hamstrings lengthening?

Methods: Three motion analysis centers retrospectively identified children with cerebral palsy, age 6-17 years, who had consecutive gait analyses with knee flexion at initial contact > 20° and popliteal angle > 35° at initial study. Three groups were considered: Medial Hamstrings Lengthening (MHL), Medial and Lateral Hamstrings Lengthening (MLHL), no surgical intervention (Control). Peak hamstrings muscle-tendon length at initial gait study was computed and categorized as 'Short' or 'Not Short'. Two outcomes variables were considered: change in peak knee extension (PKE) and change in pelvic tilt. Univariate comparisons of all variables were assessed along with a multivariate stepwise regression analysis to identify pre-operative characteristics that may predict post-operative improvement.

Results: 440 individuals met inclusion criteria. Percentage of individuals with improved PKE by grouping were- MHL-'Short': 60%, MHL-'Not Short': 65%, MLHL-'Short': 74%, MLHL-'Not Short': 74%, Control 'Short': 20%, Control 'Not Short': 19%. Percentage of individuals with worsened pelvic tilt were- MHL-'Short': 25%, MHL-'Not Short': 11%, MLHL-'Short': 42%, MLHL-'Not Short': 21% with significantly more individuals in MHL-'Short' subgroup compared to MHL-'Not Short'. Multivariate analysis suggested that pre-operative pelvic tilt and weak hip extensor strength have the largest effect on predicting post-operative increase in APT. Peak muscle-tendon length was not a significant predictor of post-operative knee kinematics or increase in APT.

Significance: This study suggests that hamstrings muscle-tendon length criteria by itself is not a sufficient indicator to recommend against hamstrings lengthening.

Keywords: Hamstrings lengthening; Muscle length; Muscle length model; Pelvic Tilt.