Preventing fluorophore photobleaching and unwanted blinking is crucial for single-molecule fluorescence (SMF) studies. Reductants achieve photoprotection via quenching excited triplet states, yet either require counteragents or, for popular alkyl-thiols, are limited to cyanine dye Cy3 protection. Here, we provide mechanistic and imaging results showing that the naturally occurring amino acid ergothioneine and its analogue dramatically enhance photostability for Cy3, Cy5, and their conformationally restrained congeners, providing a biocompatible universal solution for demanding fluorescence imaging.