Demodex mites are a common ectoparasite in nonlaboratory Mus musculus (mouse) populations. While infrequently reported in laboratory research mice, the prevalence is thought to be as high as 35% of all colonies. Here, we discuss an outbreak of Demodex within an SPF high-barrier vivarium housing laboratory mice first identified through commercial sentinel-free PCR testing. Consequently, in-house PCR-mediated identification of individually infected cages was conducted, and a successful method for eradication of secondary reemergent infection was generated via recurrent testing and empirical 12-wk treatment with 3 mg/kg moxidectin and 13 mg/kg imidacloprid. While we were unable to determine the source of our primary outbreak, the secondary outbreak was traced to nongenetically modified C57B6/J immunocompetent mice, which were capable of harboring subclinical infection below our PCR threshold. Our eventual successful eradication of Demodex confirmed, first, that in-house PCR detection is a cost-effective means of monitoring an outbreak; second, that treatment with 3 mg/kg moxidectin and 13 mg/kg imidacloprid does kill Demodex mites in laboratory mice; and third, that treatment of only PCR-positive mice is an insufficient way to control an outbreak. Taken together, our methodological approach for infestations such as Demodex suggests it is possible to eradicate them but that it requires a thorough, systematic, and aggressive treatment regimen. Moreover, we recommend that all cages derived from infected animals be treated as positive, regardless of PCR positivity, to prevent recurrent and/or persistent infections within an animal colony.