Pleomorphic adenoma is a non-cancerous neoplasm that develops in the salivary glands. Originating from minor salivary glands, it is extremely uncommon and primarily affects females. The peak incidence is observed between 40 and 60 years of age. It usually presents as a slowly growing, painless, solid tumor that does not cause ulcers on the overlying mucosa. Here, a 47-year-old woman experienced repeated swelling on the buccal mucosa following surgical extraction of a pleomorphic adenoma three years ago. The swelling was solid with clearly defined boundaries. An excisional biopsy was conducted under general anesthesia, resulting in total mass removal. The histological evaluation revealed the existence of a recurring pleomorphic adenoma. This instance emphasizes the significance of addressing this entity as a potential etiology for persistent painless and intraoral swellings.