Neisseria meningitidis is a human-restricted bacteria that is a normal nasopharyngeal resident, yet it can also disseminate, causing invasive meningococcal disease. Meningococci are highly adapted to life in humans, with human-specific virulence factors contributing to bacterial adhesion, nutrient acquisition and immune evasion. While these factors have been explored in isolation, their relative contribution during infection has not been considered due to their absence in small animal models and their expression by different human cell types not readily combined in either in vitro or ex vivo systems. Herein, we show that transgenic expression of the iron-binding glycoproteins human transferrin and lactoferrin can each facilitate N. meningitidis replication in mouse serum but that transferrin was required to support infection-induced sepsis. While these host proteins are insufficient to allow nasopharyngeal colonization alone, mice co-expressing these and human CEACAM1 support robust colonization. In this case, meningococcal colonization elicits an acute elevation in both transferrin and lactoferrin levels within the upper respiratory mucosa, with transferrin levels remaining elevated while lactoferrin returns to basal levels after establishment of infection. Competitive infection of triple transgenic animals with transferrin- and lactoferrin- binding protein mutants selects for bacteria expressing the transferrin receptor, implicating the critical contribution of transferrin-based iron acquisition to support colonization. These transgenic animals have thus allowed us to disentangle the relative contribution of three virulence factors during colonization and invasive disease, and provides a novel in vivo model that can support extended meningococcal colonization, opening a new avenue to explore the meningococcal lifestyle within its primary niche.