Prior coordination solutions shape motor learning and transfer in redundant tasks

Abstract

Motor learning does not occur on a 'blank slate', but in the context of prior coordination solutions. The role of prior coordination solutions is likely critical in redundant tasks where there are multiple solutions to achieve the task goal - yet their influence on subsequent learning is currently not well understood. Here we addressed this issue by having human participants learn a redundant virtual shuffleboard task, where they held a bimanual manipulandum and made a discrete throwing motion to slide a virtual puck towards a target. The task was redundant because the distance traveled by the puck was determined by the sum of the left- and right-hand speeds at the time of release. On the first day, 37 participants in different groups practiced symmetric or asymmetric solutions. On the second day, all participants transferred to a common criterion task, which required an asymmetric solution. Results showed that: (i) the symmetry of the practiced solution affected motor variability during practice, with more asymmetric solutions showing higher exploration of the null space, (ii) when transferring to the common criterion task, participants in the symmetric group showed much higher null space exploration, and (iii) when no constraints were placed on the solution, participants tended to return to the symmetric solution regardless of the solution originally practiced. Overall, these results suggest that the stability of prior coordination solutions plays an important role in shaping learning in redundant motor tasks.

Keywords: Bimanual; Coordination; Motor variability; Null space; Synergy; Task space.