Children's number line estimation strategies: evidence from bounded and unbounded number line estimation tasks

Abstract

This study investigates the number line estimation (NLE) strategies utilized by children aged 4-7 across both bounded and unbounded NLE tasks. Drawing on prior research, it hypothesized that younger children would predominantly employ benchmark-based strategies, with endpoints as reference points, in bounded tasks, while older children would utilize a wider range of reference points including midpoints and quartiles. For unbounded tasks, it was anticipated that both younger and older children would adopt the scalloped strategy. A total of 181 Chinese children participated, representing three educational backgrounds: Middle Class (kindergarten), Senior Class (kindergarten), and Grade 1 (elementary school). They completed the bounded and unbounded NLE tasks with numbers ranging from 0 to 50. Data analysis focused on estimation accuracy using Percent Absolute Error (PAE) and contour analyses to examine strategy use. Results revealed that all age groups employed benchmark-based strategies using endpoints and midpoints in both bounded and unbounded tasks, and applied the scalloped strategy with units of integers 5 or 10 across all tasks. Findings suggest a coexistence of benchmark-based and scalloped strategies across task types, reflecting children's intuitive estimation strategies. Furthermore, children aged 4 to 7 exhibited consistent strategy utilization, indicating a developmental stage characterized by reliance on specific reference points for estimation. This study contributes to understanding the developmental trajectory of number line estimation strategies in early childhood and emphasizes the importance of task type, learning experiences, and other factors in eliciting different estimation strategies.

Keywords: bounded number line estimation; children; number line estimation; strategy utilization; unbounded number line estimation.