Before the entry criteria for extracorporeal membrane oxygenation (ECMO) are met, newborns may require aggressive mechanical ventilation which may result in lung injury. The question arises whether the presence of a pneumothorax in these infants plays a role in the prognosis. Of the 21 newborns transferred to our hospital for ECMO, 8 were treated with ECMO. 9 of the 21 newborns developed a pneumothorax with conventional ventilation and 6 of these 9 newborns subsequently required ECMO. Infants who developed a pneumothorax but did not meet ECMO criteria and remained in the oxygenation index (OI) range between 25 and 40 for more than 2 days had a poorer prognosis. If adequate oxygenation cannot be attained with acceptable mechanical ventilation and a more aggressive ventilation results in a pneumothorax, ECMO should be considered even if the oxygenation index is below 40.